Skip to content

From the Stratamize team

Shopify Payments rejected or paused your store: what to use instead

A hold is not a rejection. What Shopify asks for in each case, the third-party providers it allows, the fee and the sales tax setting to check before you switch.

6 min read

Most store owners never think about Shopify Payments until a banner says payouts are on hold or an email says the store is not eligible. The store itself is usually still there: products, orders and customers stay where they are. The question is who processes the cards. This guide separates a hold from a rejection, then goes through what Shopify lets you use instead and what it costs.

What the Shopify Payments terms allow

The Shopify Payments Terms of Service for the United States say Shopify may suspend a Shopify Payments account, and may terminate the agreement and close the account "at any time, for any reason." They let Shopify require that some or all of the funds from a transaction be held in reserve to cover chargebacks, refunds and disputes, and they say a payment processor may keep holding funds after a closure while those are resolved.

Three other clauses are worth reading yourself:

  • Certain kinds of business are prohibited or restricted, and the lists can be updated without notice.
  • Ending Shopify Payments does not necessarily end your Shopify store agreement.
  • Where the card networks' rules require it, the processors must report a business and its principals to the networks' terminated-merchant lists, including Mastercard's MATCH list.

If payouts are on hold

A hold is not a closure, and most are resolved with paperwork. Shopify's help page on account holds gives the causes: information Shopify still needs, incorrect bank details, product eligibility, a business type that Shopify Payments does not support, and creditor or legal action.

What that page says to do:

  • Provide the information requested and reply directly to the email from Shopify. It calls this the fastest route.
  • Have the store owner do it. Only the store owner can open the Shopify Payments account details, and the hold email goes to the owner's address. Check the spam folder.
  • Read the banner in the admin. The page says "In most cases, your customers can still check out" during a hold, though you are not paid for those orders until it is resolved, and in some cases the store cannot take new orders at all.
  • For a hold that came from a creditor's legal notice, contact the creditor. Shopify cannot remove that one.

While a hold is open, keep shipping what customers paid for and keep tracking on every order. If the hold is about product eligibility, be realistic. Removing the product may resolve it. Arguing that the product is fine usually does not.

If the store was rejected or closed

Shopify's page on reapplying to Shopify Payments sets out what a rejected store has to show before Shopify will look again:

  • 6 to 12 consecutive months of processing with a third-party payment gateway after the rejection,
  • a chargeback rate that stays below 1% across that period,
  • tracking information on every shipment,
  • no negative balances.

A store with no Shopify Payments chargebacks may ask for an earlier review once at least 4 months have passed. Shopify says meeting the requirements does not guarantee approval.

Read that list again and notice what it means. The way back into Shopify Payments runs through a third-party gateway and a clean record on it. So the alternative is not a consolation prize. It is the next step either way.

Do not open a second store to get a fresh Shopify Payments account. The owner, the bank account and the products are the same, so expect the same questions.

What Shopify lets you use instead

Shopify's help page on third-party payment providers says a store can choose from over 100 credit card payment providers and can use one as its only card processor. They come in two kinds:

  • Direct providers. The customer enters the card and completes the purchase on your store's checkout.
  • External providers. The customer is sent to a checkout page hosted outside your store to pay.

A direct provider keeps the checkout feeling the way it did. For most stores that is the one to look for first.

Two costs and one setting to check first

Shopify's third-party transaction fee. Shopify's transaction fee page says the fee applies to every transaction processed through a third-party gateway. It is Shopify's charge for using someone else's processor, on top of what the processor charges. The rate depends on your plan, and Shopify publishes it on its pricing page. Put it into your margin before you choose.

The gateway and the merchant account. A third-party gateway is a connector. Behind it there has to be a merchant account that actually approves the cards and deposits the money, and both have their own fees. Ask for the full schedule, not one headline rate.

The sales tax setting. This one stops stores cold. Shopify's third-party providers page says that if a store is based in the United States and its US sales tax is managed by Shopify, it cannot use third-party payment providers. To use one, the store first has to set its US sales tax to Self-directed. Check that setting, and what it means for how you collect and report sales tax, before the day you plan to switch.

How a merchant account behind the gateway is different

A merchant account is opened in your business's name by a processor and its bank after underwriting, so your catalog and policies are reviewed before the first order.

Go in with clear eyes about the other side:

  • Underwriting can decline the store, and it reads the same product pages Shopify read.
  • An approval can come with a reserve or a monthly volume limit.
  • The account can be closed too. Disputes that climb, or products added after approval that were never disclosed, lead to held deposits and a termination, and a termination for cause can be reported to the same network lists the Shopify terms mention.
  • Subscription apps and some checkout features depend on the gateway. Confirm that every app you rely on supports the one you pick.

What underwriting usually asks a Shopify store for

  • Business documents, the owners and a government ID for the signer.
  • A voided check or bank letter.
  • Recent months of Shopify Payments payout and order reports, with refunds and chargebacks.
  • The rejection or hold notice, and what you did in response.
  • The live store: product pages that match what you will actually sell, prices, contact details, and refund, shipping and cancellation policies.
  • Supplier invoices, and lab reports or licenses where the product category calls for them.

Where Stratamize fits

Stratamize is an independent merchant services agent in Newnan, Georgia. We help a store apply for a merchant account in its own name through our banking partners and set up the gateway that connects it to Shopify. Our Authorize.net for Shopify page covers the install, the app's limits and subscriptions in detail, and our industry pages say what underwriting looks at for products such as hemp, vape and supplements.

We do not decide applications. The partner's underwriting does, and some stores are declined. Before you apply, we will look at the notice and the store and tell you what we expect to be asked. Use the "ask us first" form on our online payments page, or call (770) 629-0928.

Online payments

Start taking payments online.

We set up your gateway with your merchant account and test a live transaction with you.

Apply nowCall (770) 629-0928

Every merchant account is subject to underwriting approval.

Book a call